Skip to content

Anger Management

January 27, 2015
When we perceive any object of a familiar kind, much of what appears subjectively to be immediately given is really derived from past experience.
—-Bertrand Russell, The Analysis of Mind

I’ve learned a few more things about Stephen Pasceri, the man who murdered a cardiovascular surgeon in Boson last week.  He had money troubles involving credit card debt.   He declared bankruptcy at one point.  He tried to get John Kerry, the senator, to fix an $8,000 hospital bill.  He also has family troubles.  He sued his own aunt and uncle over a property dispute.  He seems to have been an angry and impulsive man.

John Lochman and his colleagues at the University of Alabama define anger as “a person’s response to a threat or the perception of a threat against an individual or group”.  These threats can be physical or psychological, perceptions of injustice or blame, or injury to a person’s pride or dignity.  Anger is perfectly normal.  When we perceive a danger of being hurt, the fight mechanism of anger helps to ensure our protection. The misleading element is when our mind perceives the cause incorrectly.  (Boldface added by me.)

 Ah, perception.  A pesky and persistent problem.  The way we perceive a situation is our reality, our truth.  But everybody perceives things slightly differently.  RJ Rummel, in his book Understanding Conflict and War: The Dynamic Psychological Field, has a very useful definition of perception: (https://www.hawaii.edu/powerkills/DPF.CHAP7.HTM)

Perception is a dynamic conflict between the attempts of an outer world to impose an actuality on us and our efforts to transform this actuality into a self-centered perspective. Perception is a confrontation between an inward directed vector of external reality compelling awareness and an outward-directed vector of physiological, cultural, and psychological transformation. Where these vectors clash, where they balance each other, is what we perceive.

So this is what happens: we encounter a situation.  We perceive it by interpreting the situation in the light of our experience with similar events, our cultural background, how we feel physically, and how we are used to reacting to such events.  If we perceive that we are being threatened in the situation, one of the emotions we feel is anger.

What could be perceived as more threatening than illness and death?  Health care providers work in world in which everyone feels threatened, and therefore people are scared and angry.  Research suggests that anger interferes with higher-level cognitive processes, like moral reasoning and judgement.  Anger can allow people to nurse their aggressive instincts.  Anger is part of perception, an information cue about causes and culpability, accurate or not. People frequently pay more attention to a situation when they are angry about it; they remember it.

Bernard Virshup and colleagues at the University of Southern California School of Medicine have noticed that “Many malpractice suits are brought not because of mal-practice nor even because of complaints about the quality of medical care but as an expression of anger about some aspect of patient-doctor relationships and communications.  The theory presented is that under the stress of anxiety and physical illness, some patient regress to childhood needs; physicians are not generally trained to fill such needs.  Thus, these patients, angry because of this, express their anger in malpractice suits.”  (Strategic risk management: reducing malpractice claims through more effective patient-doctor communication. Am J Med Qual. 1999; 14(4):153-9)

Or murder.

Most people manage their fear and anger in healthy ways.  Doctors, and especially nurses, are prepared for anger and understand that it is not usually personal.  The problem is, it is impossible to tell ahead of time who will take their anger in a violent direction.  Mr. Pasceri’s family has said they are shocked by his action, that he was supposedly a nice guy.  Somewhere, sometime, somebody failed to recognize a pattern of maladaptive anger in this man’s life, a habit of skewed perception.  But perception is reality, and everyone’s reality is different.

 

 

Advertisements

From → Healthcare

3 Comments
  1. Somehow our social filters have gotten suspended. This is a horribly extreme example of misdirected anger.

    Whether it is this extreme example to a non “excellent” top box score on HCAPS for a car dealership purchase experience, your clinic/hospital experience or Apple, somehow we need to stop associating everything we disagree with right or wrong with total off/on failure and decimation of our target. We need to use failure as a learning experience not to devastate people. Debi Wong, FNP Hospitalist

  2. Paula DiGiovine permalink

    Your articles about Dr. Davidson really resonate with me. I am a nurse in palliative care at the Brigham. I also am the daughter of a wonderful Dad who died of cardiac disease at 47 when I was 19 and in nursing school. His doctor was not a good one but never did I ever think of resorting to violence as an expression of the grief that I still feel today. People die. It is a part of life. I find it hard to believe that nobody could have sensed this degree of anger in Pasceri that would have motivated him to commit such a heinous act. No matter how nice he appeared to be, that is all diminished by what he chose to do with the last moments of his life. On the other hand, Dr. Davidson made the decision to take the time to speak with a grief-stricken son. He was both brilliant and compassionate. As a health care provider in an area where we encounter many volatile families, I feel a fear that one day one of us could fall victim to similar violence. As a daughter who still misses her father who died in a very sad manner in 1976, I feel so sad for all of the love , joy, and memories that Dr. Davidson’s children will be deprived of. As a partner in a very happy marriage, I am so sad for your friend Dr. Halperin. Thank you for your insightful, eloquent thoughts.

  3. Risha permalink

    Anger is perfectly normal. When we perceive a danger of being hurt, the fight mechanism of anger helps to ensure our protection. The misleading element is when our mind perceives the cause incorrectly. … Excellent point, and why this country needs to make mental health a priority. I don’t want to fear for my safety. Dr Michael Davidson’s murder was a preventable tragedy. Well said: Mr. Pasceri’s family has said they are shocked by his action, that he was supposedly a nice guy. Somewhere, sometime, somebody failed to recognize a pattern of maladaptive anger in this man’s life, a habit of skewed perception. But perception is reality, and everyone’s reality is different…. And counseling can help people come to terms with their perception in healthier ways… Wish someone invested in counseling for the son, now two deaths are mourned, the mother and the doctor who tried to save her.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

The Ideal Violinist

By Bayla Keyes

Eclectic Voices

Fiction, Monologues, Plays & More

Competing Diagnoses

How Americans talk about health care reform

Navigating Healthcare - Patient Safety and Personal Healthcare Management

A Guide to navigating Healthcare for parents, children and spouses who are concerned with managing their health and the health of their family

TurtleAndRobot.com

Children's Book Reviews

FutureDocs

Dr. Vineet Arora's thoughts on medical training, patient care, healthcare policy, with tips for trainees

Wright on Health

Making complex issues in health policy and health services research accessible to all...

Dr John M

cardiac electrophysiologist, cyclist, learner

KevinMD.com

Navigating the healthcare system

THCB

Navigating the healthcare system

Whole Mama

Navigating the healthcare system

medicine for real

Navigating the healthcare system

%d bloggers like this: